Why does kiritsugu destroy the grail

I am top tier in Super Smash Brothers Bratwurst. User Info: kaisis. Kiritsugu discovered that the Grail was corrupted, and would grant any wish upon it in the most gory and humanity-destroying way possible. In Kiritsugu's case, his wish of World Peace would make the Grail exterminate everyone until only Kiritsugu, Ilya, and Iri would be left.

So no matter who wins the Grail, everyone is screwed; hence his order to have Saber destroy it. The Grail was unable to corrupt Gil, and instead gave him a permanent body that doesn't require Prana to exist.

Meat-Knight posted That was Gil's interpretation of what happened, though in the end the Grail really just leaked out into the environment. The man who lies to himself can be more easily offended than anyone else - The Brothers Karamazov. Terrible ending. Ruined the whole show for me. User Info: y3kman. Pull that trigger, fish! If you didn't already know how it was going to end, you did it wrong.

Thanks for clearing up the ending for me guys. I was just staring at the TV going "wtf" the entire last episode since it made very little sense, but the explanations make sense.

If this was not an Aniplex anime, I would so pick this anime up on bluray since it's been the most epic anime I have seen in some time, but hey Her physical and mental capabilities surpasses those of a human, so they did not fail her during her exceptional growth, allowing her to gain self-awareness and emotions.

Her knowledge of human emotion and human experiences is limited due to having lived for only nine years without ever leaving the Einzbern castle and only having Kiritsugu to teach her about the world. This is in contrast with her inherent knowledge and reason, the crystallization of the Einzbern's wisdom accumulated over millennia, that comes with the format of a homunculus.

The result is her having both the elegance of an upper-class lady and the innocent nature of a child. Homunculi usually have their functions determined during their design process, but Irisviel developed the plan to conceive Illya after she was created.

Jubstacheit decided to allow a special case in that she was to hold multiple "functions different from the plan", allowing her to both give birth and rear Illya.

This allowed Irisviel to experience raising a child like a human mother, affecting her character in a way that Jubstacheit could not have predicted. Before meeting Kiritsugu, Irisviel had no emotion nor any sense of self-preservation beyond ensuring that she would survive as the Holy Grail. After Kiritsugu taught her about the modern world, she developed a sense of self.

She loves Kiritsugu Emiya , her husband, and Illyasviel von Einzbern , her daughter. Despite his typically restrained attitude, Kiritsugu calls her "Iri" out of affection. Though she acts as one who is sheltered and innocent, Irisviel displays a mature attitude and understanding towards Kiritsugu and the agony he suffers, as well as the knowledge that she will likely die in the war because of his actions.

She also tries to present Saber with a better impression of Kiritsugu since Saber feels her Master's cold nature derives from his belief she is unsatisfactory as a Servant because she is female. She approved of Kiritsugu's ideal and vowed to sacrifice herself for its sake, but the truth is that she never actually understood that ideal.

She simply wanted to walk the same path together with the person she loved, but — in order not to burden Kiritsugu — she decided to behave as a woman who would die for that same ideal rather than just a woman that would die for her husband.

Although she wished for Kiritsugu and Saber to keep winning and end the fighting, she had little desire towards achieving the Third Magic, which was the Einzbern family's ambition. She enjoys driving, but she is not very skilled. Kiritsugu bought her a "toy", a Mercedes-Benz SL, famous for being Japan's Yujiro Ishihara 's favorite car, to educate her about modern science.

It is a bit classical in terms of education because part of the reason it was chosen was Irisviel's own taste. While it was a custom model ordered by Kiritsugu, it lacked any substantial modifications. It was later stored in the Einzbern mansion after the Fourth War, happily becoming Illya's toy. During the 4th Holy Grail War, Irisviel became the provisional Master of Saber while relying not on the Servant System, but simply through the vows of chivalry.

Saber's actual Master is Kiritsugu Emiya, the Einzbern family's representative in that war who decided to act independently from his Servant and arrived in Fuyuki City without her. After Kiritsugu summoned Saber, he made Irisviel hide Avalon — which served as the catalyst to the summoning of Saber — inside her body so to serve as insurance while she performed her act of proxy Master. Irisviel's and Saber's role at the time was to openly take action and serve as a decoy in order to lure out enemies, while Kiritsugu worked in the shadows with his assistant, Maiya Hisau.

Due to her secluded and isolated upbringing, she is fascinated with Fuyuki City and openly explores the city with Saber as her escort during her first day. Incidentally, the fact that Saber, who could not dematerialize her spiritual body, disguised herself as a man at that time was mainly due to Irisviel's tastes, proof of how her carefree nature extended itself to her relationship with Saber. The two got along well and became close enough friends for Saber to be willing to tell the story of her past to Irisviel.

Like the Einzbern Masters of the past, Irisviel is skilled in Magecraft but is not suited for combat, making her generally left to be an observer whenever Saber entered in battle. At the same time, she also relays information to Kiritsugu through technological methods, such as tracking devices and mobile phones, which remained undetected by other Masters.

She and Saber meet with Kiritsugu and Maiya a limited number of times during the war to decide which Masters and Servants to focus their attacks on, but rarely worked together.

After Assassin, Caster and Lancer are defeated, she agrees to a ceasefire proposed by Tokiomi Tohsaka under the stipulations of "offering information about Rider and Waver Velvet 's hideout" and " Kirei Kotomine 's deportation overseas".

As the vessel of the Holy Grail, Irisviel grew increasingly weaker as the Heaven's Feel progressed since as the Servants were being defeated, her functions as a human being had to be suppressed so that her body could act as a Holy Grail.

Nonetheless, even Avalon's protection had its limitations and eventually she became physically incapacitated and was unable to do anything but lie inside a magic circle and talk. When Kiritsugu came to say goodbye before she became incapable of remaining conscious, she entrusted Avalon to him. During the final days of the war, Kiritsugu and Saber searched for the remaining Servants and Masters while Maiya was left to protect Irisviel. They are confronted by Berserker , in the guise of Rider , who abducted Irisviel and mortally wounded Maiya.

Following her abduction, she is taken to Kirei Kotomine , who asked her what Kiritsugu's wish for the Holy Grail was due his personal interest in the man. Displeased with her answer that Kiritsugu wanted to create a world without conflict and that Kotomine would never understand her husband, she was killed by Kotomine by strangling her and breaking her neck in the anime; she is rendered unconscious in the light novel.

With the war drawing to a close, Irisviel's consciousness begins observing visions induced by the Holy Grail, including one with piles of homunculi bodies with her form. When Irisviel begins dreaming of Illya asking when her father will return, Irisviel tries to comfort her daughter when she spoke of her frightening dream of becoming a " cup " being filled with " seven big lumps ". However, Irisviel soon realizes that her consciousness has merged with the Holy Grail; the tainted artifact adopted Irisviel's personality.

When Kiritsugu is submerged in the contents of the Grail during his battle with Kotomine, he encounters the spirit of the Grail in the form of Irisviel, who goes on to show him how his wish would be granted by the tainted Grail. After seeing all his loved ones massacred in order to fulfill his wish, Kiritsugu realizes his true wish was to revive Irisviel and be with Illya.

Unfortunately, he found that he could not accept the Grail, stating that the cost far outweighed any benefit it could give. Destroying the illusions of his wife and daughter, he awakens from the vision presented by the Holy Grail and decides to destroy it. The Einzbern Consultation Room takes place in the same continuity as Tiger Dojo , separate from the actual events of the story.

After Irisviel's consciousness merged with the Grail, she saved a young girl who was chased by a pack of Shades and a void-like male figure. After saving the young girl, she took her back to an abandoned school and used a room to establish Einzbern Consultation Room. She found out that the young girl had amnesia and nicknamed her as Zecchan.

Iri thought the young girl to be a Master who had lost her memories prior the Fourth Holy Grail War and died in the process.

However it turns out, Zecchan was from the future who accidentally stumbled inside the Grail. In Irisviel's story, Irisviel is from a different parallel world and she was brought by accident through Zelretch chest by Avenger and Neco-Arc.

They took the chest from the Tohsaka residence at the beginning of Irisviel's story and made it quite close to the Fuyuki Bridge in Shinto. She answered Magical Caren phone call, she revealed that she is at a different time. Irisviel enters the Einzbern mansion where she finds Berserker strangling Shirou Emiya. Irisviel communicates to Berserker and she calls him as Berserker-chan. She understood that he was panicking over the disappearance of Illya and she believes that Shirou is withholding the information.

Irisviel comforted him and she decided to help him because he is Illya's friend. Irisviel decided to punish Shirou as she believes him bullying Berserker.

Shirou decided to help her to which Berserker hits him with cheerfully. Irisviel was delighted with them becoming friends. She finds Illya in Waku Waku Splash swimming pool. Illya was confused with her sudden appearance and Irisviel explains her situation. Although she is from a different world, she still considers Illya to be her daughter and there is a heartwarming embrace from the mother and daughter.

Illya tells Irisviel that Shirou is the son of Kiritsugu. Illya tells Irisviel that Shirou is normally surrounded by girls and she complains about Kiritsugu parenting. Now since you are asking "regarding the animes' endings.

Kiritsugu's wish was for world peace, not just destroy the grail. In a certain episode I can't remember its title,but it's the one that flashes back to Kiritsugu's boyhood is shown how Kiritsugu believes that peace can be achieved, in the example with the boats by killing the larger evil. Though he understands that this way isn't possible so he trusts the grail to achieve it using super-human measures.

Now Kiritsugu's wish ended up in a devastation because by the time he summoned it there were more than one heroic spirits alive meaning that the grail wasn't omnipotent in order to create world peace in a super-human way that Kiritsugu couldn't think of.

But at that point it was strong enough to realize his wish at the human-possible level in other words in what Kiritsugu did in the past. By killing the larger evil, and thus such devastation occurred. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. Regarding Shirou and Kiritsugu's attempt to destroy the grail Ask Question.

Asked 7 years, 2 months ago. Active 4 years, 1 month ago. Viewed 9k times. Why did Shirou succeed while Kiritsugu failed? Improve this question. Hawkal Hawkal 33 1 1 silver badge 3 3 bronze badges. Add a comment.